How to conduct a 360 degree appraisal

In today's competitive environment, organisations and employees alike can benefit significantly from conducting professional 360-degree appraisals. These appraisals collect anonymous feedback from colleagues, offering a well-rounded view of an employee’s performance. This includes customer focus, teamwork, communication skills, leadership, technical know-how, and ethics.

What is a 360-degree appraisal?

A 360-degree feedback survey collects insights from multiple perspectives within the organisation —managers, peers, and direct reports. Gathering feedback from various perspectives is the key to conducting a comprehensive 360-degree appraisal. The diverse input helps create a comprehensive picture of an employee's performance and behaviour.

Mid to senior-level roles, especially those with leadership responsibilities, are perfect candidates for 360-degree appraisals. These positions involve interacting with various stakeholders and can greatly impact an organisation’s performance.

It is important to remember that the feedback collected is based on perceptions, not absolute facts. So, 360-degree appraisals should complement, not replace, the traditional appraisals done by line managers.

Related: Why an effective onboarding process is more important than you think

Benefits of a 360 appraisal

While 360-degree feedback provides valuable insights, it should not be seen as a definitive measure of competence. Instead, it serves as a valuable tool both for self-improvement and professional development.

The feedback process enhances self-awareness and helps employees understand how they are perceived by others. It can identify areas for growth and be a powerful motivator to strengthen their skills. Constructive feedback can highlight specific behaviours needing improvement, providing a clear path for development.

Conducting a 360 performance review offers numerous benefits for both the organisation and its employees:

• Improved communication: The process encourages open and honest feedback, fostering a culture of transparency and continuous improvement.
• Balanced feedback: By gathering constructive feedback from multiple sources, organisations can obtain a more balanced and objective view of an employee's performance.
• Professional development: Insights from a performance appraisal can help employees identify specific areas for development, leading to targeted training and skill enhancement.

Steps to conduct a 360-degree appraisal

1. Select a representative group: To gain a well-rounded perspective, it is essential to collect feedback from a group of 5 to 10 colleagues who interact regularly with the employee. This group should include managers, peers, and direct reports to provide a well-rounded perspective.
2. Choose the data collection method: Online surveys are commonly used for gathering feedback in 360-degree appraisals due to their efficiency and anonymity. Alternatively, face-to-face interviews or structured discussions can be conducted for more in-depth insights, especially in smaller teams or organisations.
3. Ensure anonymity: Guarantee respondents that their feedback will remain anonymous. This assurance encourages honest responses, which are essential for the appraisal's effectiveness.
4. Communicate the purpose: Clearly explain the purpose of the 360-degree survey to all employees. Transparency helps prevent misunderstandings and ensures everyone understands the goal of fostering professional growth and development.
5. Involve the employee: Ask the employee to complete their own survey. Self-assessment allows the employee to reflect on their performance and provides a baseline to compare with the feedback from others.
6. Set a minimum interaction period: All participants should have worked with the employee for at least six months. This requirement ensures that the feedback is based on sufficient interaction and observation.
7. Compile and analyse data: Once the performance feedback is collected, compile and analyse the feedback data to identify patterns and trends. Look for consistent themes that can provide valuable insights into the employee's behaviour and performance. Utilise software or tools designed for data analysis to simplify the process.

Human resources should be involved in successfully implementing a 360-degree appraisal system. HR professionals are often responsible for designing the feedback system, ensuring the anonymity of responses, and guiding managers and employees through the appraisal process.

By effectively managing the collection and analysis of feedback, HR can help create a culture of continuous improvement and development within the organisation.

Related: How HR needs to evolve to support the future of work

Addressing common challenges

Implementing 360-degree appraisals can pose various challenges for organisations. Here are some common challenges and strategies for addressing them:

1. Resistance to feedback: Some employees may resist participating in the appraisal process due to fear of criticism or discomfort with receiving feedback. To address this challenge, emphasise the benefits of feedback for personal and professional growth and create a supportive environment that encourages open communication.
2. Concerns about anonymity: Employees may be hesitant to provide honest feedback if they are concerned about anonymity. To alleviate these concerns, ensure that feedback mechanisms are confidential and that respondents' identities are protected. Communicate clearly about the anonymity of responses and reassure employees that their feedback will be used constructively.
3. Difficulties in data analysis: Analysing large volumes of feedback data can be overwhelming and time-consuming. Consider using software or tools designed for this purpose to simplify the data analysis process. Focus on identifying key themes and trends in the feedback to inform decision-making and action planning.

The comprehensive nature of 360-degree appraisals transforms feedback into a valuable learning experience for employees, helping them identify strengths and areas for improvement.

Best practices for follow-up after performance appraisal

Follow-up is essential for ensuring that the insights gained from the appraisal process translate into meaningful action and improvement. Here are some best practices for follow-up after the appraisal process:

1. Regular check-ins: Schedule regular check-in meetings to review progress on development goals and discuss any challenges or obstacles encountered. These meetings provide an opportunity to offer support and guidance and adjust goals as needed.
2. Revisiting development goals: Periodically revisit development goals to assess progress and make adjustments as necessary. Celebrate achievements and milestones and set new goals to continue the growth journey.
3. Ongoing support and resources: Provide ongoing support and resources for employee growth and development. This could include access to training programs, coaching or mentoring opportunities, and other development resources.

By addressing challenges and implementing best practices for follow-up, organisations can maximise the effectiveness of their 360-degree appraisal process and foster a culture of continuous improvement and growth.

Related: Workplace flexibility a top priority for candidates: report

Tips for handling negative feedback

Handling negative feedback can be challenging but essential for personal and professional growth. Here are some tips for helping employees effectively manage challenging feedback:

1. Maintain a positive mindset: Approach negative feedback with an open mind and a willingness to learn and grow. Instead of viewing it as criticism, see it as an opportunity for improvement.
2. Seek clarification: Don't hesitate to seek clarification if feedback is unclear or ambiguous. Ask for specific examples or suggestions for improvement to understand better the areas needing development.
3. Develop action plans: Use the feedback as a catalyst for action. Identify specific steps you can take to address the feedback and improve in areas of weakness. Set realistic goals and timelines for implementing changes.
4. Focus on solutions: Rather than dwelling on the negative aspects of the feedback, focus on making improvements. Use the feedback to identify areas where you can excel and make a positive impact.
5. Seek support: Don't be afraid to seek support from mentors, colleagues, or a coach. Discussing feedback with others can provide valuable insights and perspectives, helping you navigate challenges and develop effective strategies for improvement.

Fostering growth through constructive feedback

360-degree appraisals are a valuable employee performance management tool for fostering professional development and improving overall organisational performance. By carefully collecting and analysing feedback and focusing on constructive criticism, organisations can help employees develop their skills and behaviours, ultimately contributing to the company's success.

Performance evaluations can significantly boost employee engagement by fostering a culture of transparency and continuous feedback to track progress, making employees feel valued and involved in their personal and professional development.

Implementing these appraisals thoughtfully and effectively ensures that the organisation and its employees can reap the benefits of this comprehensive feedback tool.

Read more:
Critical Skills Needed for Gen Z to Succeed in the Digital Economy
How to create content for people with colour-blindness
5 interview questions to ask to tell a great candidate from a good one

Start a hiring conversation with Michael Page to find out how you, too, can reap the many benefits of a leading global recruitment agency.